Eclectic Voices

Fiction, Monologues, Plays & More

A Moment For Horror

a screamPart of the Eclectic Voices Halloween Edition
A thought from Eclectic Voices Coordinator Chelsea Sutton

I took a class once on horror films (Yes…I took many odd classes in college.  Money well spent.)  We spent a lot of time watching clips from Texas Chainsaw Massacre and analyzing the Scream franchise, and even though the whole thing wasn’t quite as shocking or gruesome as what comes up when you do a Google search of “morgue” (I mean, Jesus, that might have been a mistake to do on my work computer), I came away with a solid understanding of how the horror genre plays out in our lives.

(Side Note: the horror film class was taught within the German Department…for unexplained reasons.)

Even if you don’t enjoy horror, you should not disregard the genre entirely (over-used tropes of nearly-naked blondes running from masked murders notwithstanding).  Horror reflects society and the human condition on it’s most base level – tapping into the very fears that run below the streets of the sometimes flimsy facade of civilization we’ve built to protect ourselves.

You could say horror is a necessary evil.  HA.

I’ve always been a big fan of horror or, perhaps more specifically, the creepy, weird or unusual.  I grew up reading Goosebumps and one of the most terrifying children’s anthologies every published: Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark I was known to pout when no one wanted to tell scary stories around the camp fire and they opted to sing that goddamn “Make New Friends” song again instead and presumably hold hands or something. 

Welcome to my childhood.

Welcome to my childhood.

I was obsessed with the scifi/horror/weird shows The X Files and The Twilight Zone (I say ‘was’ as if those obsessions have somehow disappeared) and I still hold out that the horror-comedy The Frighteners is one of the best films ever made.  Ever.

And I have my reasons.

The Unknown & The Uncanny

The horror stories that rise above mere slash and hack gore, whether they are natural or supernatural in nature, are playing with the two most frightening elements a story can possess: the unknown and the uncanny.

“The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown” ― H.P. Lovecraft, Supernatural Horror in Literature

They differ in an important way.  The unknown is, as Lovecraft says, the oldest fear there is.  When we lived in caves, we feared what lurked in the dark.  In today’s world, the same fears fired up after the September 11 attacks, when a different culture, a different religious group that many weren’t familiar with took to the Terror Stage (you can look at World War II when other groups were singled out and labeled as the unknown).  Humans fear what they don’t understand, what they can’t see, the hidden enemy hiding in the crowd – our imaginations are always more horrible than reality, which is why the reveal of a monster is best left until the final stages in a movie, if it happens at all.

The uncanny refers to a Freudian concept where something is both familiar, yet foreign – it has a feeling of the uncomfortably strange, and often taps into the desires of the Id.  Our societal taboos can be uncanny.  An inanimate object that is suddenly animate; a physical deformity or change; doppelgangers.  Our familiar perception is twisted, sometimes even slightly, to create something terrifying.

(Side Note: Okay, uncanny comes from a German word…so that might explain the film class.  Maybe.)

Death is the ultimate fear: everything about it is the unknown, and a dead body is the ultimate in uncanny.  Google image search “morgue” and you’ll get my meaning.

Both the unknown and the uncanny can reflect fears prevalent in society at the time a story is created. For example:

Zombies vs. Vampires: Politics in Horror

You’ve probably heard this theory but, not considering individual analysis of certain movies or stories, in a very generalized way, the popularity of zombies or vampires reflects the political climate of the day in the US.  Zombies tend to be more popular when there’s a Republican in the White House.  Vampires are more popular when Democrats are in power.  If you’ve ever seen any of the Night/Evening/Day/Morning/Mid-day Snack of the Living Dead Movies, this may be abundantly clear to you as the message (consumerism, for example) gets more blatant as the movies go on.  Democrats fear zombies because they are mindless consumers who destroy non-conformists.  Republicans fear vampires because they are overtly sexual deviants and loners from society who feed off of others.  You can see where this is going.

Pictured: affordable healthcare.

Pictured: affordable healthcare.

Here’s a  Cracked article about this that’s fun.  Still no explanation for the sparkly vampires, however.

Powerlessness & Morality

We’ve built whole civilizations, towering cities, and great big things that get us from one place to another.  We post on facebook every five minutes to make sure people know we have a pretty darn good life.  Our twitter feed is blowing up, yo.

But in the end, there is an aching feeling of powerlessness, of loneliness, of extreme vulnerability.  Horror strips us of our big buildings and shiny cars and internet connections.  We must face what we are and what we’ve done and what we’re capable of.  There is nothing to hide behind and it’s painful, though cathartic, to experience it.

Horror also lives in the realm of the morality tale (sometimes to its detriment…only the virgins don’t get murdered? really?)  Stephen King is a great example of this, as his tales are always grounded in morality and presence of both good and evil in every person.  He is a humanist – which is why he’s never taken to Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of his novel The Shining, which Salon tackled recently:

The great theme of King’s fiction is the capacity of the average person — especially working-class or similarly humble men and women — both for evil and for heroism. Although there’s almost always a battle against a supernatural antagonist in King’s books, the best of his novels hinge on the protagonists’ struggles with themselves….King is, essentially, a novelist of morality. The decisions his characters make — whether it’s to confront a pack of vampires or to break 10 years of sobriety — are what matter to him. But in Kubrick’s “The Shining,” the characters are largely in the grip of forces beyond their control. It’s a film in which domestic violence occurs, while King’s novel is about domestic violence as a choice certain men make when they refuse to abandon a delusional, defensive entitlement.

Both the novel and the movie are great in their own right – though one is terrifying due to moralistic reasons, and the other because, essentially, we’re all powerless and under Stanley Kubrick’s control.

Which might be the most terrifying thought of all.


Chelsea Sutton holds a BA in Literature from The College of Creative Studies at UC Santa Barbara. Her plays have had readings and productions in Santa Barbara, New York and Los Angeles and she is currently participating in workshops with the Skylight Theatre Playlab and The Vagrancy Writers Group, as well as spearheading ECT’s writers group, Eclectic Voices. Her play The Dead Woman, was recently named a Semifinalist in the Eugene O’Neill Playwrighting Conference 2013. Her fiction has appeared in The Best of Farmhouse Magazine, The Catalyst, Spectrum, and Fictionade, and she was the 2011 Winner of NYC Midnight’s Flash Fiction Contest. Her story The Tick and the Tocking received Honorable Mention in Glimmer Train’s Short Story Award for New Writers. She is a member of the Los Angeles Female Playwrights Initiative.

3 comments on “A Moment For Horror

  1. jfolschinsky
    October 7, 2013

    Reblogged this on Amused to Death and commented:
    Very good article in the latest edition of Eclectic Voices (Halloween Edition) by my friend and co-coordinator Chelsea Sutton.

  2. Taylor
    October 9, 2013

    Horror is a wonderful genre, although I’m definitely more enticed by morality and could-be-true-life horror than supernatural – but ultimately, it’s how well the story is told. I mean, c’mon, a good story well told? Doesn’t really matter what it’s about. I suppose that’s why I like the writer-voice of Stephen King but not necessarily all of his stories – all the way through at least. God knows, he keeps me turning the pages. Recently read his “11/22/63” which is supernatural but in a very believable way somehow – and the choices (I keep thinking about “Sophie’s Choice” for some reason – a case could be made for that being a horror story, right?) are very human choices. In other words, not black or white, not all good or all evil…

    Interesting article, Ms. Sutton. Would have loved to take that class with you…

    Although I do have to say that “true life” horror is often more horrific than fictional horror, at least for me. I’m always so shocked by the horrible evil that humans are sometimes capable of. Sorry – I’ve been watching too much news lately…

  3. seankozma
    October 13, 2013

    Fantastic article, Chelsea!

    I’m a big King fan myself, for the same reasons you highlight above.

    One of my other favorite horror artists is David Cronenberg, whose horror films were all deeply grounded in “body horror” – that shared human experience that we are all of us trapped in these fleshy meat sacks that begin rotting and decaying on us from the moment they are created, allowing us to be while simultaneously destroying us. I always felt Cronenberg gave the best gore, because he used it to remind us that the odds heavily favor us experiencing some kind of horrifying decay, decrepitude or bodily catastrophe before we die.

    As they say, “We shall all meet, by and by.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: